The Philistines in the Harper government are cutting the CBC budget by a further ten percent. No big surprise there – they have an inexplicable hatred for Canada’s national broadcaster, even though the CBC has spent years trying to “balance” their reporting in a way that they hoped would avoid the perception that they are being “critical” of anything that Harper does.
The CBC is seen as a motherhood thing by many intelligent people, and indeed, in most parts of the world a strong non-commercial (aka State) broadcaster is considered to be one of the essential parts of the media universe.
Sweet though that is, the fact is that CBC has long ago ceased to offer much of real value to Canadians. Perhaps the time has come to just drive a stake through its heart and sell off the assets to Bell or Rogers.
I’ll ignore CBC TV entirely, since it’s indistinguishable from commercial TV. Yes we all love Rick Mercer, but when was the last time that CBC TV did drama on the level of the BBC, or news coverage that differed in any way from CTV or even SUN TV? Truth is, years of budget slashing have left them without the resources to do anything creative, and without the courage to really report – especially on government.
But Radio you say! (With fuzzy memories of Peter Gzowski coursing through your veins) We must save Radio!
Nonsense.
ONE) The vast majority of Canadians not only don’t listen to CBC Radio, they don’t even know it exists. Yes, there was a time when it was a thread that most Canadians shared, but those days are long gone.
TWO) Far too much of CBC Radio is filled with Toronto hipster irony and smugness. I’m really sick of the oh-so-cool attitudes and cynical repartee of Brent Bambury, George Stroumboulopoulos, Sook-Yin Lee, and endless other made-in-CBC land “stars”. I don’t want to know how cool you think you are guys. Honestly I usually don’t want your opinions or quips. I either want hard facts, or I want to hear the ideas of your guest.
THREE) CBC’s Literary programs are mediocre. I actually loved the Canada Reads panel on Q this year, and the passion of the panelists was enough to make me actually go out and read the damn books. The same cannot be said about any of the other book shows on CBC. The fawning adoration of Shelagh Rogers and Eleanor Wachtel grate horribly, and offer nothing like intelligent insight into the authors or books. If anything an inclusion on Writers and Company or The Next Chapter makes me assume that I don’t want to read a book.
FOUR) Definitely Not The Opera – it was lame when it was created, and lame it remains. Too, too, too cute by far, which is usually the sign of a show that has long since ceased to have new ideas. The root problem seems to be that DNTO, like all of the similar “variety” shows at CBC Radio (Q excepted) seems to be hosted and produced by people with minimal life experience, minimal breadth of knowledge, and minimal interest in anything that their hip friends aren’t already talking about. In other words, its all far too light weight.
FIVE) Ron Sexsmith – Nuff said – To all of those who can’t figure out why commercial success has eluded him, it’s because he’s whiny and annoying.
SIX) Anything that comes under the heading Political Coverage. Look CBC, in a week when Harper has attacked you viciously with an axe, you’re reporting that the Budget is really No Big Deal, Very Restrained, Not As Bad As People Predicted, and Responsible. What does he have to do to get you riled up? Castrate Peter Mansbridge??? By any number of measures this budget is a slash and burn attack on Canada and the things that matter to most Canadians. Our national broadcaster should be expressing outrage and alarm, not sucking up to the people who just cut them off at the knees.
SEVEN) Rex Murphy – See Ron Sexsmith above, but with a Newfie accent and a thesaurus up his butt.
EIGHT) The Vinyl Cafe – Once upon a time a faux Lake Wobegone may have been novel or cute, but this CanCon adaptation of A Prairie Home Companion is tired in the extreme.
NINE) The Current. One show that should see some praise, if only for last fall when they did a number of EXCELLENT programs about poverty in Canada and actually allowed POOR PEOPLE to talk on the radio instead of pundits and professors. That groundbreaking work led to…. well, nothing. But there have been about a hundred and forty five reports on Egypt, and Syria, and Iran. I guess poor people in the Middle East are just so much more important than poor people down the street.
TEN) The Fraser Institute, Canadian Taxpayer’s Federation, Canadian Federation of Independent Business et al. Let’s be honest. These are in no way impartial or balanced commentators – they are right-wing ideologues who add nothing to a discussion. TAX BAD! REGULATION BAD! MINIMUM WAGE BAD! SOCIAL PROGRAM BAD! Surely there are a few thousand intelligent, informed experts who could be called in instead of these Harper cheerleaders.
ELEVEN) Government PR flacks – sorry, Ministers. If all they have to offer is talking points off cue cards, and if they refuse to deviate one iota from those points, much less answer an actual question (assuming that someone at CBC Radio will actually ASK the obvious question that’s staring them in the face), then they are of no value to anyone – you’re wasting my time. Give me some intelligent analysis, not Tory blah blah blah.
TWELVE) Endless Repetition – I understand the concept – having multiple programs examine an issue from different angles. The problem is it has devolved into: Morning Edition: Bullying. We’ll talk to someone who was bullied. The Current: Bullying: we’ll talk to a bully (preferably from Cairo or Iran). The Noon Show: Bullying: We’ll take your calls (Until the gardening show, anyhow). The Afternoon Show: Bullying: We’ll talk to a teacher. MORE does not always equal DEPTH. Sometimes it’s just, well, repetitive.
THIRTEEN) Radio Two – Used to be all Classical music all the time. Now it’s all pop music alternating with Classical all the time. WHY? WHY? I love music, I know music, I’ve programmed music. I never listen to Radio Two because their “classical” programming is dull as dishwater, and their pop music is flaccid and repetitive. There is lots of amazing brilliant “classical” music being performed and recorded, and lots of utterly stunning pop, rock, hip-hop, folk, and soul music too, but you won’t hear it on CBC Two. Buck 65 – what the hell happened????
FOURTEEN) Radio Three – it’s a web site. Stick on some Google ads to pay for it.
Are there any real reasons to keep CBC Radio? Go check out the CBC Archives pages. Listen to Peter Gzowski and Joe Ghiz make salad, or An Introduction to Al Purdy, or Gzowski again with Mary Collins on Capital Punishment. Or from 1970 – a discussion of media ownership and freedom of the press. Or Joni Mitchell and Vicki Gabereau about polio and the music business.
I’ll state flatly that there’s nothing on CBC radio today to match the quality of these clips.
I probably come very close to fitting the CBC’s target demographic: middle aged, educated, a book reader, with wide ranging tastes in music, a healthy interest in politics, and a follower of news. The problem is that everything except Jian Ghomeshi and Q either bores me or irritates me.
So instead of the death of a thousand cuts, lets just kill the beast off. We can always listen to BBC on-line.