Ok, I’ll give this a try.
1) “If you are using 10.4 use this guide.” Checked my version of OS X and changed to the right page and read:”Both computers should have their firewalls turned off, or have the relevant ports opened” Hmmmm.. would be nice if he told me which ports are “relevant.” I’ll just ignore that….
2)”Ensure all computers are on the same subnet” Check!
3)”Ensure that the Windows PC to have a user account with a username and a password and to know the shortname and password associated with the Mac.” Ok, I wish he had told just what “the shortname” is… this is starting to feel like trying to configure Linux using MAN pages…
Went to the Mac Help and searched on “what is my shortname?” Failure….
Ah… searched on just “shortname” and got two hits.
Went to System Preferences | Accounts and found out that my short User Name was “barryrueger”.
On the PC it’s “Barry Rueger”.
Now, I’m sure that one of these pages said that the two systems had to have the same User Names and passwords, but there’s no mention so I’ll ignore that right now.
Bingo! Now it works.
4) Setting up sharing on the Mac.
“Ensure that Personal File Sharing and Windows File Sharing are checked”
Again, I wish the guy had noted where those settings are found. Oh well, Check! and Check! again.
5) Setting up sharing on the PC
“Do not try and share the whole drive only share folders, trying to share a whole drive can result in unexpected errors.” Eh? What’s that? Yeesh what a pain. I really would rather just share the entire E drive, the one that hold all documents, seperate and apart from system and program files.
OK, rather than change the settings on 100 folders, I dragged them all into a new one called “Shared” and we’ll see if that works.
6) Ok, if this guy is to be believed this should all work now.
Finder -> Go -> Connect to Server Check!
Type in smb://IP Address of PC
Opened a command prompt window, typed in ipconfig, got the IP address for the PC and entered it… Check!
Clicked “connect” and watched the “Connecting to smb://192.168.1.100″ progress box. For a loooong time.

Ok, forget that…. let’s try the other direction. PC to Mac!
7) “My Network Places” Check!
“Add Network Place Wizard” Whoops… that’s XP, and I’ve got Windows 2000…
Ok, found the Win2K equivalent, and it wants the IP address for the Mac. Hmmm… where the heck is that found?
“Type in \\IP Address of Mac\Mac Username”
System Preferences | Network | TCP/IP
Check!

Hmm……
Interestingly I can bring up a Terminal window on the PC and ping the Mac, but can’t ping the PC from the Apple machine.
I just though was reminded that I was running ZoneAlarm on the PC, so let’s shut that down. Holey Moley! Suddenly the ping command goes wild on the Mac!
Yes, it works, and what’s more, it looks like you can share an entire drive, rather than individual folders.