It is a day to be dreaded. An anniversary that I approached with a certain unease.
Yes, I am trembling in anticipation of the orgy of media and political activity which is planned to take advantage of the fifth anniversary of the attack on the World Trade Centre and Pentagon.
Already I have heard endless repetitions of the now hackneyed “It Was a Day That Changed The World™.” (Always spoken in your best Voice of Doom intonations).
If your definition of “The World” includes only New York, Hollywood, Washington, Iraq, and Afghanistan this would be true.
I doubt that homeless children in Rio de Janeiro either know or care about the few thousand Americans killed in NYC. I find it unlikely that the unfortunates trapped in any of a dozen African hotspots think that their lot is any better or worse because of the actions of Al Quaeda.
And I am sure that the great population of the world’s most populous countries – India and China – don’t really see this as having any relevance at all.
Still, I live in the shadow of The United States of America, that controller of all North American language media, so I am supposed to Remember Where I Was on That Day™, and Swear That We Will Root out Terrorism™, and Back Our Ally, the U.S., in Their Fight For Democracy™.
As I sit here I am wondering just how 9/11 Changed The World™ for Americans. I was in the U.S on that day, and know that much of the population was struck dumb by fear and lack of understanding.
Still, in practical terms I can see only two things that have happened to the people of that country.
The first is that air travel has become a nightmare of bizarre and largely ineffective restrictions, where travel consultants suggest wearing flip flops to the airport to avoid delays.
The second, more insidious, is the rapid and unyielding campaign by the American establishment to strip away civil liberties and long held rights. It seems that in the eyes of the current U.S. administration there is no liberty so sacred that it cannot be limited or eliminated in the name the Fight against Terrorism™.
I would be tempted to suggest that 9/11 also gave the U.S. government the freedom to invade foreign countries and overthrow governments, but am currently reading The Best and The Brightest, and an reminded that this attitude is one that is decades old. 9/11 may have made them bolder, but Afghanistan and Iraq are hardly the first countries to fall under the heel of the American military.
The beauty of the War on Terrorism™ is it’s vagueness. It can be applied to anyone, in any place, in retribution for almost any action. And because of that vagueness it will never, ever end.
Oceania was at war with Eurasia: therefore Oceania had always been at war with Eurasia. The enemy of the moment always represented absolute evil, and it followed that any past or future agreement with him was impossible. … And if all others accepted the lie which the Party imposed -if all records told the same tale — then the lie passed into history and became truth. ‘Who controls the past,’ ran the Party slogan, ‘controls the future: who controls the present controls the past.’ … All that was needed was an unending series of victories over your own memory. ‘Reality control’, they called it: in Newspeak, ‘doublethink’.
If you wish to commemorate 9/11 break out your dogeared copy of 1984 and be chilled by the parallels.